Investigation · November 5, 2026
A New Jersey Judge Linked Five Sunrun Cases Over Disputed Signatures
A New Jersey judge identified five Sunrun cases involving disputed customer signatures. The court record shows a recurring question about what customers saw and approved when sales documents were signed electronically.
November 5, 2026
Magda Diaz said she signed one page on a salesperson's tablet at her Clementon home. The document Sunrun later relied on was a 25-year power purchase agreement bearing electronic signatures attributed to her and her husband. In a July 2025 opinion, Chief U.S. District Judge Renée Marie Bumb declined to send the dispute to arbitration before the parties investigated whether the homeowners had agreed to it.
Bumb named four other New Jersey cases involving what she called “strikingly similar allegations of forged customer signatures.” Together with Diaz, they form a five-case court record. Her footnote turns a single dispute into a documented New Jersey case trail.
Last reviewed November 5, 2026.
Why the Diaz signing record drew scrutiny
Diaz said the salesperson presented one page on his tablet as part of checking her eligibility for a government rebate. She said she did not see or sign the longer agreement. Her husband said he did not sign anything. According to the court's account of the filings, Sunrun emailed Diaz at 2:27 p.m. asking her to review and sign an agreement that already carried an 11:30 a.m. digital signature timestamp. The records described in the opinion indicated that the agreement was sent, viewed and signed in under three minutes. The sequence puts the signing record at the center of the case.
Sunrun pointed to different IP addresses associated with the salesperson's and customers' purported signatures. Bumb found a genuine dispute about whether Diaz had agreed to arbitrate, denied the motion without prejudice and ordered limited discovery into consent. The later docket records a 2026 settlement and dismissal.
The cases the judge connected
| Case | Disputed record and latest verified action |
|---|---|
| Diaz v. Sunrun | Diaz and her husband disputed signatures on the PPA. The court ordered discovery into assent in July 2025. The case later settled and was dismissed. Opinion · Docket |
| Baldassano v. Sunrun | A mother and daughter disputed signatures and acknowledgment of a 20-year agreement and said it had gone to an incorrect email address. The original complaint and exhibits are public. Bumb's Diaz opinion cites a November 2022 order directing discovery into whether they viewed, acknowledged or signed the agreement. |
| Valerio v. Sunrun | The homeowners alleged signatures on several documents were forged. In September 2025, the court ordered limited discovery into whether they voluntarily entered the disputed agreement. The case was dismissed by stipulation in January 2026. |
| Pereira v. Sunrun | Bumb identified Pereira among the similar cases. The available docket records discovery and a December 2025 dismissal. The docket number is 1:24-cv-06651; the Diaz footnote prints 06551. |
| Tighe v. Sunrun | Bumb also named Tighe. The accessible docket names Bright Planet Solar and Green State Energy Solutions alongside Sunrun and records Sunrun's crossclaim against those companies. |
In Diaz, Baldassano and Valerio, judges ordered further examination of disputed assent. The Pereira and Tighe dockets complete the set Bumb identified.
What the older Vivint records show
The Baldassano exhibits include Vivint Solar ethics training from before Sunrun acquired Vivint. An exercise describes a salesperson copying a homeowner's genuine signature onto a revised agreement without obtaining authorization for the new version. The answer key treats that as forgery. Another section bars representatives from checking signature boxes for customers.
Other filed exhibits include a Mosaic lender alert about a rep-created email account used to access or sign a credit application and sworn testimony from a former Vivint resolutions employee about sales representatives handling delivery of agreements. The documents show why the displayed agreement, the signing history, and the delivery address each matter.
A published New Jersey appellate decision in Knight v. Vivint likewise examined what a homeowner saw on a tablet when she signed and an agreement that included the name of a former homeowner who did not participate in the sale. The appellate court vacated an order compelling arbitration and directed a hearing on assent. The related Reilly federal case grew out of the same transaction.
New Jersey's 2019 consent order with Vivint Solar Developer required a meaningful opportunity to read an agreement before signing, electronic execution and immediate delivery to the customer's email address.
What a homeowner can check
The signing history can reveal details a finished agreement leaves out. Compare every version of the agreement, the device and email used to view and sign it, the time stamps, acknowledgment boxes and the delivered copy. The Diaz opinion shows why a judge examined those details instead of treating the displayed signatures as the end of the inquiry.
For New Jersey complaint filing and consumer help, see New Jersey solar consumer resources. The Office of Consumer Protection handles consumer business complaints. The Board of Public Utilities provides assistance with regulated utility matters. Related reporting covers Sunrun's long-term contracts and a checklist for preserving solar records.